News 
 State News 
 Livestock 
 Cattle 
 What Bindaree wants from beef's leaders 

What Bindaree wants from beef's leaders

07 Mar, 2010 04:00 AM
WHILE it believes the beef industry is already over-represented by peak bodies, Bindaree Beef wants to launch another beef industry body to represent disaffected beef producers at a State and Federal level.

The role of the task force proposed by Bindaree wasn’t fully defined, but the intent appears to be the creation of an expert panel capable of representing the views of Bindaree and its supporters to the highest levels of government.

There is a need for an alternative body "that is democratic and producer run", Bindaree spokesperson Leigh Belbeck told the Armidale Beef Industry Forum.

However, at least intially, Bindaree proposes to elect those who sit on the task force, and has initially nominated four people, three of them unknown to the industry and none of them full-time beef producers.

Ms Belbeck said lawyer Norman Hunt, the architect of the NSW "truth in labelling" legislation, would head up the body.

Mr Hunt was earlier described by JR Mcdonald as "the smartest man in the history of this industry".

Business economist Dr Selwyn Heilbron, the author of several industry reports, including a 2000 report on the live animal trade and a 2002 report into the effect of government charges on meat industry competitiveness, has according to Ms Belbeck agreed to sit on the task force as the "economic brains".

Ms Belbeck has also asked Max Eastcott, general manager of Gwydir Shire in northern NSW, and Dr Ian Fielding, a retired cancer surgeon, to join the body.

Mr Eastcott, who has had occasionally controversial terms as general manager with the Byron and Margaret River councils, is seeking to get collaboration between 113 major agricultural councils around Australia.

Dr Fielding, a cancer surgeon for 30 years, has since 1997 been producing beef in his retirement in the NSW Northern Rivers area.

Ms Belbeck believes his experience in advising State Government on medical system issues will assist the task force in its dealings with government.

To fill out the board, Bindaree is looking for nominations from cattle producers.

"You will have to trust us, I suppose, to do a selection process on this, but this is only year one—there has to be a starting point," Ms Belbeck said.

"If we can get three, four, five producers on this board, along with Norman, Max and Professor Heilbron, I think we’ve got a committee that is truly representative of the beef industry."

However, Ms Belbeck did not clearly define the role of the task force, except that it would "start liasing with State and Federal politicians on what we’ve been talking about today", including a national beef grading system.

"We need this task force to get involved in anything that pertains in any way to the beef industry so your voice is being heard—there’s no more confidentiality agreements taking place.

"We need this task force to put in submissions into all the enquiries we’re calling for. And they need to be constantly reporting back to the people here, so that you are kept fully aware, but most importantly, when you’re dissatisfied, you let these people know.

"They’re taking direction from us."

The "snag", Ms Belback said, was funding for the body.

Bindaree have apparently approached the Red Meat Advisory Council (RMAC) for funding from the Red Meat Industry Reserve Fund, but have been rebuffed.

"If we can’t get the funding from RMAC, the people on the board are unfortunately going to have to fund themselves until we can get access to those funds and get changes," Ms Belbeck said.

Ms Belbeck also outlined a range of other campaigns that Bindaree hopes to run, including:

  • repopulat ing the inland using instruments like zonal taxation;
  • getting the government to take on all the costs associated with NLIS and AQIS;
  • pour more resources into boosting domestic beef consumption;
  • reconside r the MLA’s international role, including the possibility of shutting down MLA’s international offices and letting exporters and government trade offices handle meat marketing.
Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Aricle 25th Feb 10 The Australian, Author Colin Masters, expert in neurodegenerative diseases. Other mysteries remain, Masters who travels Britain, says while cattle are no longer fed bone meal that caused crisis, handful of cases BSE are continually still turning up. Now the contaminated feed cycle has been eliminated there's the possibility that there has been enviromental contamination of the farms and pastures and that will take a long while to leach out of the system. some other facts: May 15th 2009 cow BSE Canada infected 80mths. BSE has long incubation period about 4 years. Aust is one of only 10 counties recognised by WTO as having negligible risk of BSE. 4% of world's beef produced in Aust. The value of beef exported annually 7 billion dollars. These are from articles read on the internet. So you can make your own minds up to their validity.
Posted by tj, 7/03/2010 9:50:21 AM, on The Land
Oh My God, JR says "down with all these peak bodies they're all rubbish, rubbish I tell you!!" Now here, pick my 'democratically elected producer group'. Finally the truth, and the truth as we know shall set us free. What a crock!!
Posted by Realist, 7/03/2010 1:57:53 PM, on The Land
first of all to the so called "journalist" of this article Mr Cawood-thanks again for your objective and non bias views...once again we see another article from you written on behalf of the governement funded bodies.I know that you were at the meeting in armidale and yet your articles continue to show that year's of the MLA and other bodies propaganda have filled your brain to the extent you cannot comprehend people disgageeing with their views...time to show some objectivity in reporting bud...cause your a sham
Posted by DJ, 7/03/2010 7:51:21 PM, on The Land
Now the detail comes out. What a bunch of hillbillies and to think that some in the beef industry would seriously consider these dimwits to represent them. Keep the detail of your alternatives coming JR and Co. This is the beginning of the end for your rubbish solutions and your self interest objectives. Keep Leigh Belbeck as a spokesperson for the cause - it will reduce the time we have to listen to any more of this garbage. You'll all be laughed out of town. At last the hype fades into the distance and someone is held accountable for recommending solutions and improvements. Pity they haven't got any and what they have suggested is a joke.
Posted by Truth be known, 8/03/2010 6:40:37 AM, on The Land
DJ... this actually is an objective article. There is no judgement; Mr Cawood presents what Bindaree wants without commenting on whether it is good/bad/etc. Obviously you're a sore Bindaree loser who's just cut that it doesn't give unwarranted bias to your own opinions and agenda.
Posted by Enlightened, 8/03/2010 7:30:09 AM, on The Land
"...the intent appears to be the creation of an expert panel capable of representing the views of Bindaree and its supporters to the highest levels of government" Wow - how self serving is that?! If you're not Bindaree or a supporter does that mean you're not represented? So peak bodies are ok then JR? Just so long as they toe your party line... sounds like an AWI board in the making.
Posted by Theo, 8/03/2010 8:21:45 AM, on The Land
Isn't it strange, Enlightened, that there are such people as DJ, who seem to be intellectually incapable of even simple comprehension of the written word. DJ, re-read the article (presuming you actually read a first time), paragraph by paragraph, and tell me which paragraph(s) are not factual or are biased and/or not objective. You are right on the money, Theo, in your comment about Bindaree's very undemocratic ambitions, very poorly disguised as somehow democratic. Perhaps a reread of "Animal Farm" would be instructive at this time.
Posted by Bushie Bill, 8/03/2010 8:56:37 AM, on The Land
Think the democratically elected producers from the livestock boards of NSW Farmers and Agforce and NT Cattlemen will be a little bit stunned to hear this. So the elections that have put them up to these committees have been deemed invalid by JR? The thousands of producers from those groups who did vote in these elections must also be annoyed that they have been paying fees to groups deemed invalid by JR! The handpicking of some token producers to back the 'smartest man in the beef industry' on JR's committee is somehow more democratic? Sorry what? Did the labour day holiday get swapped with April Fools? Be very sceptical of people claiming democratic ideals with no membership base, not democratic SYSTEMS or a constitution that defines the democratic process.
Posted by Skeptic, 8/03/2010 12:59:34 PM, on The Land
Bushi Bill / Truth Be known / Realist...Do you guys have common rural or meat knowledge?? If so, you would understand that our current Government bodies aren’t performing and have been “Sipping away on Cafe lattés”, "MAINTAINING" their positions in their cushy leather chairs for far too long. The problem is that the meat/livestock game is getting tougher, the government have made ZERO impact on these tough times as witnessed by all. For the benefit of the industry we need to get "go getters" like JR McDonald, who are willing to roll up their sleeves and put together a team to implement some forward planning, something that the Government has failed to do. Where is the forward planning from these peak bodies? …. How are our industry funds getting distributed?... Obviously not to evenly. Why is it that domestic consumers are so naive and so bluntly informed of different packing methods? Is it because MSA decided to make things Mumbo Jumbo, to confuse the hell out of consumers… and aim there campaign at butchers and processors? Gee you can’t expect people to put on the knife belt every time they want to purchase meat. MSA have brain washed themselves - but not the public.
Posted by TOM HEAVY, 8/03/2010 2:57:44 PM, on The Land
“Truth be Known” – you are dead right, this is the beginning of the end, not for JR McDonald and the gang, but for all the dead weight meat & livestock entity groups, that we as producers/packers/sellers have been carrying for the past decade. This is a true wake-up call for the MLA. P.s. Why would you want anybody laughed out of town that creates more than 700 jobs? Just what the economy needs! Let me guess, you have been brain washed by the Labor Party's GFC is over, let’s spend more money scandal! Great objective, if you're 5 Y/O in a toy shop. “Bushie Bill” - Great read “Animal Farm”. However if you want to know more about the beef industry or even comment on meat articles, you will have to broaden you’re reading capacity to “non fictional” rather than fictional. Let’s hope you and your allies aren’t using this as a guide. PS – Please refer to your comment made to “DJ” “intellectually incapable of even simple comprehension” – I'm assuming that you had a typo on the word “Bushy"…Nice title considering you’re a city slicker. No doubt you people have some better solutions that could benefit our industry, rather than mock.
Posted by TOM HEAVY, 8/03/2010 2:58:37 PM, on The Land
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Bindaree Beef's JR McDonald
Bindaree Beef's JR McDonald
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
05 March, 2010
POLL
Q: What do you think the outlook for your commodity will be this year?

Highly positive
(6.1%)

Positive
(24%)

Neutral
(34.5%)

Negative
(23.3%)

Highly negative
(12.1%)

Total Votes: 429
Poll Date: 28 February, 2010
BLOGS
04 March, 2010

Most popular articles

SPRAY AWARDS NEWS MREC



The Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...