News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Political 
 Shooters vote under fire 

Shooters vote under fire

12 Jun, 2009 04:00 AM
A conservative voter backlash is set to hit The Shooters Party and prominent Christian Democrat, Reverend Fred Nile, after legislation to protect fertile farmland from mining was narrowly voted down in State Parliament.

Reverend Nile and the two Shooters Party representatives in the Upper House sided with the Labor Government last week to swing the crucial vote on the Mining Amendment Bill in favour of mining companies whose expanded activities are causing widespread anger, particularly in northern NSW.

The North West is considered the heartland rural support base for the Christian Democratic Party (CDP) in NSW.

Reverend Nile’s vote was accused of being hobbled by Labor because he was granted an extra $25,312 a year on his parliamentary salary by a Labor Government-Shooters Party majority vote two years ago.

The 19 votes to 20 split last week left the mostly pro-farmer gallery glaring at Reverend Nile and the two Shooters Party representatives, Robert Brown and Roy Smith.

The two Shooters MPs have many supporters in rural areas, particularly in the mining region around Cessnock, but that did not stop some of the public who yelled out “shame”.

“I think it’s the rowdiest day we’ve had in more than 20 years,” Reverend Nile told The Land this week.

Greens Upper House MP Lee Rhiannon – a surprising heroine for farmers last week – pledged to bring her proposed legislation back to parliament “within the year”.

“Every month that passes, more damage is being done,” she said.

Former Christian Democrat colleague, Reverend Gordon Moyes, who split from the CDP three months ago, said Reverend Nile and The Shooters Party had become the governments “junkyard dogs”.

The president of Gloucester Residents in Partnership, Gary Ferris, said it was a pity Reverend Nile could not put his Greens prejudice aside.

“Fred, you’ve been around way too long, it is time to retire. You’re nothing more than a puppet of the Labor party,” Mr Ferris said.

Reverend Nile, who plans to visit northern NSW in the coming months to bolster his disgruntled support base, said he voted according to his conscience.

The CDP branch at Narrabri already faced possible closure because of flagging membership.

Reverend Nile, the longest serving member of NSW Parliament, rejected claims his specially created role as assistant to the deputy president of the Upper House swayed his thinking.

The proposed changes to mining legislation aimed to help threatened farms in the Liverpool Plains and Gloucester areas.

But even if passed in the Upper House, the State Government still retained a solid majority in the Legislative Assembly and would have defeated the Bill there.

However, farmers saw last week’s Bill as a symbolic potential win in their ongoing battle.

Reverend Nile argued he too was voting to protect farmers – from the Greens.

He said the Greens concocted most of NSW’s anti-farming laws in recent years and would “crucify” farmers if they grew more powerful.

The Greens had manipulated farmers opposing mining to make headlines, he said, and hinted that they may soon try to stop farmers from using bore water.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1


comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Reverend Fred Nile, this bill was a straight choice - support farming, or support mining - it was that simple. Voters take note.
Posted by shame, 12/06/2009 8:59:39 AM
It's a sad day when those elected to support us turn against us. I voted for the Shooters Party, I farm, I eat, I shoot..... Keep this up and you'll lose the donkey vote that will not vote for the major players. A VERY BAD Call boys, after so much good. On a bright side, finally the Greens can see some benefit to farmers, about time we worked together, all in all we basically want the same thing.
Posted by Rebecca Dance, 12/06/2009 9:55:36 AM
Everything is simple for Greens. Coal miners don't need jobs. 25% of NSW's electricity comes from Liddell Power Station. It is a coal based generator. NSW needs coal and it needs farmers. It doesn't need Greens though.
Posted by Farmer's Friend, 12/06/2009 11:40:06 AM
It's obvious that these puppets have no integrity or ethics in their role in government. They sided with a corrupt and arrogant Labor party who should never have allowed the exploration licenses to have been granted to BHP and a Chinese mining company on some of the most fertile and productive soils in Australia, if not the world. Up till recently the only support farmers gladly received was from the Greens - the only party that showed compassion, intelligence and a thorough knowledge of the terrible plight facing many farmers on the Liverpool Plains. These other puppet clowns couldn't care less that our future as farmers, and a secure food/water supply is in danger. SHAME ON YOU NILE AND SHOOTERS PARTY.
Posted by brett sanders, 12/06/2009 11:40:49 AM
...but will the voters remember?
Posted by Ngobody, 12/06/2009 12:26:33 PM
The Christian Democrats and Shooters Party members did not display any reasonable arguments against the Bill and used their time as an excuse to attack the Greens.
Posted by Lifestyle, 12/06/2009 1:42:42 PM
Fred Nile - How dare you let your anti Greens views cloud this issue. It's down right amazing that farmers and the Greens have agreed on something. I thought you represent Right to Life - then how come you vote against something that threatens our lives - the very valuable land that provides our food. Any potential threat to this land through the short term gain in mining under it is not to be tolerated. What good are jobs if we don't have food?
Posted by Maybalene, 12/06/2009 4:13:08 PM
It's clear that many farmers, and their 'farmers friends', don't really have an idea of just how helpful, supportive and 'on the ball' the Greens have been to us farmers on the Liverpool Plains. They are the ONLY party that have been listening to us, vocally critical of what the state government has done, and also acting against the terrible situation that is unfolding. The Nationals have only recently, and somewhat pathetically, come on board to throw their opinion, so too the Liberals.

'rebecca dance' has a great point - it is time we all started working closer together, as to more and more people it is becoming obvious that we broadly do have quite similar goals in many issues. Many farmers out this way have completely changed their opinions of the Greens after receiving much needed and appreciated assistance. If it wasn't for the Greens we would be in a much bigger and messier hole than we are at the moment. It's a shame more closed minded and outdated people can't see through their ignorance and bigotry.

Posted by brett sanders, 12/06/2009 7:42:17 PM
Can 'farmers friend' let us on the Liverpool Plains know how we are meant to live side by side, or on top of, coal mines? Have you ever driven through the Hunter Valley - a once idyllic and picturesque area that is completely trashed by mining in many of its areas? Is this secure long-term employment? Is it as sustainable and long term as agriculture? What of the devastating environmental consequences? The landholders and numbers of schools that have been told they can't drink their tank water due to the heavy metal concentrations? What of the disrupted and wrecked aquifers, creeks, springs? What of the subsidence of land? And the complete disruption to many farmers livelihoods as a result of forced acquisitions of land, increased trucks on roads, coal dust etc? Please do yourself and the rest of us a favour and look at what massive negative consequences these mines can have on a region. Yes they provide some jobs and export earnings and fuel for an outdated and extremely dirty energy industry - but that's it!!! The negatives far outweigh the positives...and certainly is not using our intelligence!!!!!
Posted by brett sanders, 12/06/2009 7:54:07 PM
We are faced with unprecedented problems. The Greens, the Nationals and the Liberals are to be congratulated that they put aside long held prejudices and worked together in the interests of food producers and consumers. This is not just a fight between farmers and coal miners. It relates to circumstances which are unprecedented in our lifetimes. Solutions are needed and our representatives must work co-operatively to bring forward solutions, regardless of party positions and personal attitudes.

The Greens, Nats and Libs in the Upper House have begun this process. Our Government must recognise that they will exclude themselves if they persist with this narrow and destructive position. They might be set for self-destruction. They must not take us with them.

Posted by Ken Johnson, 12/06/2009 8:34:12 PM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Upper House members Robert Brown and Roy Smith from the Shooters Party at the SSAA shooting range in Sydney.
Upper House members Robert Brown and Roy Smith from the Shooters Party at the SSAA shooting range in Sydney.

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 14%
2) Apple iPhone 4 32GB43 plans 6%
3) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 1%
4) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
5) Samsung Galaxy S15 plans 4%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press

Circle8
 
FOL EMAIL SUBS


SA
WA
QLD
VIC
WA
SA
QLD
VIC

The Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...