News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Thoroughbred breeders want mining ban, too 

Thoroughbred breeders want mining ban, too

14 Dec, 2010 02:47 PM
HUNTER Valley thoroughbred breeders have slammed the NSW Government over its failure to release its promised strategic land use strategy for coal mining in the state.

Hunter Thoroughbred Breeders Association (HTBA) released a 10-point plan it says will end land use conflict and restore balance in Australia’s thoroughbred breeding heartland.

It calls for a moratorium on all new exploration and mining decisions in the Hunter Valley pending an independent, comprehensive environmental and socio-economic assessment of the cumulative impact of mining on both the area and the thoroughbred industry.

It also calls for a ban on all future mining in the Hunter Valley where such activities threaten thoroughbred breeding operations.

HTBA President Wayne Bedggood said breeders were disappointed that the government had promised a strategic review of land use but the cabinet sub-committee chaired by Planning Minister Tony Kelly was yet to release its report.

"Neither the terms of reference nor an issues paper has been released for the strategic plan,” Mr Bedggood said.

“The Hunter Valley community has not yet been consulted. Community engagement is obviously critical to any meaningful review,’’ he added.

Mr Bedggood argued that thoroughbred breeding should be recognised as an industry of state significance.

He called on the NSW Government to create a dedicated agriculture minister, establish an Independent Sustainable Agriculture Agency, an Independent Planning Commission and laws that respected and recognised landholder property rights.

Vinery Stud general manager, Peter Orton, said Premier Kristina Keneally had promised her government “would not jeopardise the growth” of the thoroughbred industry, and State MP for the Upper Hunter George Souris had called for a pause on new mining while cumulative impacts were properly assessed.

“We believe that both the government and the Opposition need to back those statements with decisive action,” Mr Orton said.

Arrowfield Group chairman John Messara said breeders were not against mining, but would not stand by at watch a 150-year old industry become defunct.

“We want to see an end to the sterilisation of productive agricultural land in the Hunter Valley,” he said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The NSW minerals industry has always been a vigorous advocate of strategic land use planning, so that there is more clarity and direction, not just for mining or thoroughbred breeders, but for all industries.

We support the NSW Government process set out a strategy for coal in NSW. It is important for all industries and stakeholders to have their say. But we are frustrated that it is taking time to get going.

While there is a need for strategic land use planning, there is no reason why the rigorous planning and assessment process currently in place can’t continue while strategic land use plans are developed.

We support a practical approach to the challenges ahead, not one that will disadvantage the people of regional NSW that rely on diverse economies where farming, thoroughbred breeding, mining, viticulture and other industries can all prosper.

The Government and the Opposition have both said they do not support a moratorium. Moratoria are impractical and ignore the realities of business and investment. It would be like asking our farmers to stop working the land while the Federal Government undertakes consultation on the Murray Darling Basin Plan.

Posted by NSW Minerals Council, 14/12/2010 4:55:31 PM, on The Land
@The Minerals Council.

We local residents & rural land holders are also frustrated. We are frustrated by the fact that there has never been a strategic plan for the Mining expansion other that that they will award mining exploration leases where ever they like with no local consultation or investigations on the impacts or even notifying those effected it is happening. We are also frustrated by the fact we are thrown of our land and the land ripped up and rendered useless after a few decades of mineral exploitation. We are also frustrated and angered by the fact that this expansion continues even though guidelines are being developed and we have no way of knowing or checking that any new mining will meet the new guidelines or even be reversable if it doesn't. The practicalities of businesses shouldn't be the governing factors in deciding if a rural area is to be de-populated, the land ripped up and the water resources destroyed.

Frustration has turned to anger regarding these self interested pro mining propaganda statements trying avoid the real issues to avoid a moratorium only appease Mining companies accounts at the permanent loss of rural land & communities.

SHAME!!!

Posted by SPARKS, 15/12/2010 12:30:09 PM, on The Land
p.s. NSW MC.

Your logic & analogy regarding the MDB suggestes it would be desireable to protect argi business & investment to continue issuing water allocations while they draw up the strategic plan to govern the allocation of water.

This would be true if the MDB was part of the mining boom and was as one sided in the process of awarding rights and preventing interference in the final approval processes.

But your illogical self interested opinion shows that the mining industry is used to getting it's own way and if it doesn't the NSW Gov. will step in and change the rules so they do regardless of the Social & environmental damage.

The roylaties & fees have blinded the State Gov. to their moral, social & environmental irresponsibity. No one believes the twisted logic, or reasoning OR that money justifies anything. when you drive past the moonscapes, the many empty farm houses that the friends that were forced to leave used to live in, or see the clouds of dust blowing over the countyside or see the irrigation farms sitting idle with the water piped off to mines you understand what mining is really about and it isn't JUST business, investment or lines on maps.

MORATORIUM NOW.

Posted by SPARKS, 15/12/2010 12:57:04 PM, on The Land

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES

Most popular articles

Advertisement



The Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...