News 
 National Rural News 
 Opinion 
 Comment 
 Cattlemen driven to desperation by Canberra 

Cattlemen driven to desperation by Canberra

15 Aug, 2011 10:07 AM
Tomorrow, a road convoy will set off from Port Hedland in Western Australia for a journey across the country. Two more convoys will leave Perth and Cairns on Thursday. By the end of this week, 11 convoys will be in motion, all heading to a single convergence point next Monday. This is the ''convoy of no confidence''.

The convergence point is Canberra. The show of no confidence is in the federal government.

''We will be driving across the Nullabor,'' one of the organisers, Matt Thompson, told me. He and his wife, Janet, are cattle producers in Western Australia. They are part of an industry mobilised by anger towards the government.

But the protest is about much more than cattle.

''We were hesitant to participate due to time and cost, but two things put us over the line,'' said Thompson, who will be driving a campervan. ''The first was reading the 340-page Clean Energy Bill 2011 [the federal carbon tax bill], and the other 12 bills to which it is attached.

''The words 'global warming' are not mentioned but monetary transfers to the United Nations are outlined and power is given to an international consortium of finance companies. This bill makes the Copenhagen treaty [COP15] look like a children's book.

''There was also Marlee Ranacher's heart-wrenching story on 60 Minutes about the impact on her and her family of the government's knee-jerk decision to ban exports of cattle to Indonesia. So we decided to drive across the Nullarbor as part of the convoy of no confidence in the federal government.''

In Canberra the assembled protesters will call for a double dissolution of Parliament so the government can seek a mandate for the sweeping changes it is proposing, especially the carbon tax which the Prime Minister, Julia Gillard, ruled out during last year's election campaign. The idea for the convoy came from the president of the National Road Freighters Association, Mick Pattel, who proposed that some heavy freight trucks leave Katherine, in the Northern Territory, and drive all the way to Canberra.

The emotional fuel for the protest was the devastation caused to the live cattle trade by the government's sudden decision to shut down live exports after the ABC broadcast images of cruelty to cattle in an Indonesian abattoir.

That was a month ago. The project has spread and thickened since then. ''Because of the sheer number of people wishing to be involved we had to have more [convoy] start-up points to allow people greater access,'' Pattel said.

Three issues are driving the participants: first, their sense that the government has comprehensively mismanaged and misunderstood the live-cattle export industry; second, a belief in the high cost and pointlessness of the proposed carbon tax; third, a sense that the Gillard government, with low public support, no majority in Parliament, and no electoral mandate for its policies, has lost legitimacy and should seek a mandate by holding a new election.

The spark for all this was the broadcast on May 30 of the ABC's Four Corners program A Bloody Business, which showed footage of Australian cattle being brutalised in a primitive Indonesian abattoir.

The great irony is that the program has set off a disaster for the live-cattle industry that could cause thousands of cattle to die of starvation as feed runs out and fuel for water pumps cannot be paid for. The loss of export income will amount to hundreds of millions of dollars this year alone.

The federal politician most expert in the live cattle trade, Senator Chris Back, a veterinarian and former consultant to the trade, described the images broadcast on Four Corners as ''repulsive'' but he also proposed practical advice which, if taken, would have prevented a government suspension of the live export trade.

Back, a Liberal senator for Western Australia, urged the rapid installation of Australian-made cattle crushes in the key Indonesian abattoirs. These are standard equipment on Australian properties and would have allowed livestock to be stunned before slaughter, as they are in Australia.

Instead, on June 7, the government suspended the entire trade. Two months later, it is fitfully allowing a resumption of live exports and has set aside $30 million in emergency compensation. The industry has taken a huge hit. Jess Sullivan, whose family runs Cave Creek station in the Northern Territory, described the impact of government intervention in a letter that Senator Back quoted into Hansard:

''Yes, the images [on TV] were horrific, we don't accept it, and we don't condone it … I'm sure the program's makers were delighted with the interest sparked by their production but … did they really mean to bring an entire industry to its knees and [damage] Australia's relationship with Indonesia?

''Was throwing hundreds of stations into an uncertain future, that could see three generations of some families lose everything, what they intended? Because, congratulations to them, that's what they have achieved.''

Shane Stafford, a stock and station agent in north Queensland, is backing the convoy. ''Every day I talk to hard-working people under severe financial stress … because someone in a cosy office in Canberra is squeezing the life out of them.

Senator Back told me: ''Everyone in the convoy to Canberra will be making a significant sacrifice in terms of time, money and energy. They want to draw attention to the plight of the bush and the feeling they are being ignored by the federal government. This convoy is driven by sheer frustration.''

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I have been told our PM needs the whole term to get her pension so there is no way she will step down.

One can always wish.

Posted by Jen from the bush, 15/08/2011 2:24:49 PM
Hey Jen, can you give me one logical reason why she should step down, other than to give into illegitimate political fuzzy-brained self-serving hyperbole?
Posted by Bushie Bill, 15/08/2011 3:05:24 PM
The world dictionary defines fascism as; “any system of government in which property is privately owned but all industry and labour are regulated by a government that rigorously suppresses all opposition.”

By that definition the Gillard regimes Clean Energy Bill 2011 should be renamed the Fascistization of Australia Bill 2011.

From coast to coast there are already legions of compliance police on both State & Local Government payrolls & the Gillard regime is establishing more at a rate that will make Abbott’s proposed, 15,000 member green army look like a handful of girls scouts.


Posted by jock, 15/08/2011 4:10:03 PM
I just about broke my heart, when we just could not find a way to participate in the convoy. I hope the opposition takes as much note of his as the government and is especially careful when formulating their policies before the next election. I wish everyone a safe trip and hope we can push a double dissolution through; it's the only way!
Posted by Right Royally P...ed Off, 15/08/2011 4:29:15 PM
Bushie Bill -

1. Total incompetence

2. History of waste

3. NBN is obsolete

4. A voice that would rasp elephant toe nails away.

Posted by ggwagga, 16/08/2011 7:46:49 AM
jock, get a life and some reality; Right Royally, get a brain. If you believe this expensive wasteful stunt will have any positive (in your terms) outcomes, let alone bring about a double dissolution, you are totally without intelligence and any understanding and experience of the real world. The only thing missing in this farce is the Boofhead Twins, Bob and Barney. They really know how to turn on a comedy.

There is another way, you fool, and that is to accept the decisions of a legitimate government elected a year ago. What is so hard about that, you twit?


Posted by Bushie Bill, 16/08/2011 8:43:38 AM
Bushie Bill, It surprises me that your only reaction to this article can be defammatory remarks addressed to others who have responded. (I could ask if defammatory is too large a word for you, bit I'm not into slanging off at people I don't know!)
Posted by mrs e, 16/08/2011 10:03:38 AM
Bushie Bill, judging by the steady flow of resignations by senior ALP figures, all is not well within the hallowed halls of the party. Word is that once Kevin gets out of hospital he will go straight for Julia's jugular. The aim being to be back in the Lodge for Christmas. If Kev calls an election to get a mandate, its good night ALP! NSW showed the way.
Posted by dagworth, 16/08/2011 12:08:53 PM
mrs e

You must be new to this forum because regulars all know that bushie bill is the leader of the forums resident gang of social delinquents.

The only people they defame are themselves.

Posted by jock, 16/08/2011 12:35:09 PM
mrs e – Try not to misunderstand B/S Bill. He is actually trying, very hard in it’s only known way, to reach out to it’s target audience and to convert this audience to it’s point of view. It achieves this with the use of such words as ‘rednecks’, ‘brain-less’, ‘illiterates’, ‘boofhead’ and the like, including my favourite….. ‘pothole’.

Problem is, it seems not to work, which unfortunately and with gusto only convinces B/S Bill to re-double its efforts using the very same technique.

At the end of the day B/S Bill is, if nothing else, entertaining.

Posted by PAYG, 16/08/2011 1:34:10 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
14 August, 2011
12 August, 2011
15 August, 2011
14 August, 2011
POLL
Q: Are you in favour of Australia's commercial kangaroo industry?

Yes
(94.3%)

No
(5.7%)

Total Votes: 522
Poll Date: 08 August, 2011

Most popular articles

Advertisement



The Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...