News 
 National Rural News 
 Livestock 
 Cattle 
 Uproar over foot and mouth import proposal 

Uproar over foot and mouth import proposal

23 Dec, 2008 02:15 PM
The peak cattle lobby, the Cattle Council, is in a rage about an approved recommendation to bring live strains of foot and mouth disease into Australia for research.

It is seeking urgent meetings with the Federal Government to try to reverse the decision.

Despite initially welcoming the Beale report as a review into Australia’s quarantine, the Cattle Council of Australia says it overlooked one key recommendation – the importation of the FMD virus, to develop tests and vaccines in Australia.

Such an import could have damning and long-standing consequences for the industry.

The Federal Government last week gave in-principle approval to all 84 recommendations in the report, which recommends one of the biggest overhauls to quarantine seen in Australia for more than 100 years.

But the recommendations also include plans to overturn a 30-year ban on bringing the live FMD virus to Australia.

It says such imports are “vital” to Australia’s research efforts at places like the Australian Animal Health Laboratory, based near Geelong.

Cattle Council president Greg Brown says the council fiercely disagrees with the report’s view that such imports are “vital” to Australia’s quarantine efforts.

He says allowing the strain onto Australian shores would instead be “the biggest folly any industry, or Government, could commit.

“Cattle Council will violently oppose any moves to import live foot and mouth disease."

“There have been countless attempts to do so in the past and all have failed.

“I have never heard of a reasonable case put to justify the imports.

"I still don’t think they are justified for the purposes of research.”

Mr Brown says the Government “will need to do some explaining” as it is aware of the livestock industry’s longstanding policy of opposition to live imports of such virus.

“We’ve seen how human error can cause outbreaks, as happened in Britain last year,” Mr Brown says.

“If the same mistake were to happen here, it would not be months, but years before Australia could regain any ground in its many red-meat markets.

“I would estimate even 10 to 15 years to rebuild to a level pre-FMD – it would be that bad.”

Mr Brown said he is “embarrassed” Cattle Council did not previously pick up on the recommendation within the Beale report last week, giving it then, full and overwhelming support.

“It seemed a positive document, but we overlooked that recommendation," he says.

“We were not aware of any proposals to do this and to find later that this recommendation is in the report, and given approval, is very concerning.

“We rise and fall on bio-security.

"Our energies should be directed at stopping the disease coming in accidentally, not on purpose.”

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1


comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I'm not in the cattle/dairy industries myself, but if this importation of the FMD virus gets up, we all might as well forget the beef and dairy industries.

We'll be importing the products from these industries on top of everything else. Let's hope all major cattle players take up on this matter.

Posted by Don't blame me... I voted Liberal, 23/12/2008 4:35:36 PM
AQIS couldn't keep EI out of mainstream Australia. In the end, it only affected the health of the horses, and was overcome with isolation and vaccination.

After that failure, has this Government had the slightest thought as to the effects a FMD outbreak could have to the Australian Community?

Get Real! This idea of importing the FMD virus for research here has to be knocked on the head.

Posted by Equine Influenza, 23/12/2008 4:46:40 PM
If the Govt thinks the research is vital, then send the researchers to countries where FMD already exists! Don't bring it here! If KRudd can give 70 million to Toyota, he can afford to send a few of our scientists off shore to study this disease rather than bring it in and cripple our livestock industries.

Do we all remember how calicivirus escaped? Foot and mouth disease will too!

Posted by Brindi, 23/12/2008 9:20:27 PM
May as well sell the farm. If they allow this into the country, it would only be a matter of time before we had a disaster. Look at EI. We would need more than a NLIS data base to control that sort of disease in a country of our size.
Posted by disheartened, 24/12/2008 5:48:31 AM
This is just another way of trying to rid the Aussie farmer, as if they haven't put enough strain on us to try and survive.They won't be happy till we have to import all products. I agree with all the above comments. Let's hope that the Cattle Council of Aust can over rule on this one.
Posted by Aussie Farmer, 24/12/2008 7:20:02 AM
Hi Aussies...from a pommy farmer.

Re FMD, I thought we had all the lunatics in the UK. Some must have escaped!

Posted by paul, 24/12/2008 8:01:55 AM
They must be insane. Is it not the case that the last major FMD outbreak in the UK was caused by aerosol drift from a 'secure' R&D facility?
Posted by jerburah, 24/12/2008 8:27:55 AM
Common sense has died. Are these people insane? We trade on our disease-free status. Why deliberatately import this disease. Send the researchers overseas.
Posted by Helen Clark, 24/12/2008 9:42:57 AM
I am shocked to think that any clear thinking person would even consider bringing in live FMD. Serrated tussock escaped from a research lab at Wagga many years ago. Has John Carter seen the recommendations?
Posted by Heaven help us, 24/12/2008 10:47:52 AM
It be prudent to share information with international research laboratories and send our researchers to their facilties. It is peculiar that we have not learned some very basic biology lessons from the past, and we thereby commit ourselves to further biosecurity risk.
Posted by Nexus Agronomy, 24/12/2008 10:50:31 AM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Cattle quarantined before slaughter  in the UK during the recent outbreak there.
Cattle quarantined before slaughter in the UK during the recent outbreak there.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
POLL
Q: Which Aussie farm produce will be part of your Christmas feast?

Pork
(16.3%)

Turkey
(14.8%)

Beef
(7.1%)

Lamb
(8.7%)

Seafood
(13.5%)

All of the above
(32.9%)

None of the above
(6.6%)

Total Votes: 392
Poll Date: 19 December, 2008

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC SJ



 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...