News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Political 
 Lib disarray over climate deal 

Lib disarray over climate deal

23 Nov, 2009 06:38 AM
ANGER has deepened within the Opposition over emissions trading, with internal criticisms that chief Liberal negotiator Ian Macfarlane has become too close to the Rudd Government.

Opposition figures were shocked and infuriated when the Government revealed it would not announce its compromise offer on emissions trading until tomorrow - only to discover that Mr Macfarlane had asked for the delay.

Mr Macfarlane admitted he and Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull decided last Monday - when it was clear negotiations would go into the weekend - that the Opposition party room should consider the outcome tomorrow and the plan should not be unveiled by Labor until then.

The move gives opponents of the scheme less time to mobilise against it.

Mr Macfarlane said he had not wanted the Government to pre-empt the party room discussion with an announcement.

''My goal is that the MPs and senators hear the outcome of the negotiations from me - not from the press, not from the Government,'' he said.

But he neglected to tell the manager of Opposition business in the House, Christopher Pyne, who was taken by surprise when Climate Change Minister Penny Wong outlined the timetable on television yesterday morning.

Yesterday one Liberal said a ''Stockholm relationship'' - in which someone is kidnapped and becomes sympathetic to their kidnappers - had developed between Mr Macfarlane and Senator Wong, saying: ''They're getting too close.''

Preparing to wrap up the deal, which benefits farmers, heavy industry and coal producers, Mr Macfarlane flagged that he and Mr Turnbull would push the Opposition hard to accept it.

The negotiations were ''getting there'', he said. ''I'm expecting to have a proposal to put to the party room. I'm optimistic it will be accepted.''

This week Mr Turnbull faces the biggest test so far of his leadership.

His challenge is to get the deal through his party room - after it is endorsed by a shadow cabinet meeting on Tuesday morning - and then minimise the number who cross the floor.

The foul-up over the timetable has further soured the mood in the severely divided Opposition ranks.

Even before, there were rumours about the possibility of one of the hardliners moving for a leadership spill.

Some Opposition sources think Mr Macfarlane and Senator Wong are conspiring to railroad the party room.

Senator Wong said the Government would put a clear offer to the Opposition tomorrow morning, after cabinet and caucus meetings.

But she said the Coalition negotiators already knew broadly what was likely to be offered.

Opposition Senate leader Nick Minchin, a hardliner who does not want a deal, criticised the timetable, saying it raised questions about the Government's bona fides.

It would make it ''very difficult for the Opposition to properly consider what the Government puts'' and whether that made the emissions trading scheme bills worthy of support.

West Australian Liberal climate sceptic Dennis Jensen said he was appalled at the delay.

He said there would be a push at the party meeting for a secret ballot on the deal.

Amid criticisms from environmentalists and the Greens, the Government will ''green up'' part of its scheme, with plans to give more incentives to household action to cut emissions.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Would any sane Australian sanction a commitment by any side of Australian politics to a list of climate change policies that will effect Australian jobs and our economic future, prior to the Copenhagen conference? It would be the brain dead that react unilaterally, especial when their own population is of no insignificance, compared to the total global reduction, which is considered necessary. The driver is ego, electoral promises and hype! The opposition painted as the ogres, were in fact the original leaders, but sensible enough to realise the world must act in unison. Malcolm Turnbull’s original offer, of a fully bipartisan approach to climate change, was rejected remember; fortunately there is now a growing number of Australians finally seeing the light. The opposition has been boxed into the position of being electorally dammed if they do not agree, but are likely to get stuffed if they do. The old saying 'screw you', may be well understood by many, but do we want to screw ourselves? It will be an interesting week in Canberra!!
Posted by graham, 23/11/2009 7:48:56 AM
The deception in this whole thing is incredible. The East Anglia Centre for Climate Change was hacked last Friday and emails released that prove that gobal warming scientists have falsified information. None of this has been released in the Australian mainstream media. The whole global warming issue is now a proven SCAM.
Posted by Bill, 23/11/2009 8:31:51 AM
McFarlane and Turnbull have become Rudd cronies! Time to get rid of them and get some real opposition Links to cLIEmategate at www.twawki.wordpress.com
Posted by twawki, 23/11/2009 8:59:51 AM
Very sensational, Bill, but you do not provide even a hint of evidence to support your ridiculous claim. Are you so overcome with the conspiracy theory bug that you are unable to think?
Posted by Bushie Bill, 23/11/2009 12:32:52 PM
links to the letters here: http://www.anelegantchaos.org/cru/search.php

Links to commentary here: http://wattsupwiththat.com/

Posted by paul, 23/11/2009 2:35:14 PM
Google 'sky falls on the chicken littles'. Seems like it's all over for the green brigade as green stock is starting to get dumped.
Posted by been, 23/11/2009 3:01:12 PM
News.com.au have picked it up. Laugh! Sub- Headline with 2 global warming disaster stories. Basically climate scientists are crying in frustration at their inability to find real proof of global warming and their models failure to predict. The recent global temperatures that are cooling (especially when the best they can spin it to is a levelling off and still a major departure from their models). Also the what is now standard ranting about what they would like to do to people who disagree with them.
Posted by Qlander, 23/11/2009 3:20:31 PM
It looks like we have a scientific civil war going on. Kevin has sided with the CO2s and if they go down, he'll go down with them. Malcolm hasn't yet made a firm commitment to either side but he is running out of time to make a choice.
Posted by Qlander, 23/11/2009 4:24:53 PM
People have had enough of this climate change spin. First it was gobal warming, then catastrophic climate change, now climate change. With climate change predictions failing to materialise, people have had it. Politicians like Vic Ag Minister Joe No Helper with 70 advisors are on the nose, their carbon foot print must be seen to be believed, yet they spin the line do as I say not as I do!
Posted by Seth, 23/11/2009 9:47:10 PM
Why is it that the reporting and headlines seem to always start from the point of view that the opposition are idiots for opposing such a wonderful scheme? We still have not had a full public media debate about Climate Change, it would appear that we are all supposed to just fall in line and blindly accept that the sky is falling and we should just do it. The mere fact that any opponent to the Climate Change theory is automatically called a sceptic is in itself absurd. How any piece of legislation can possibly be fully considered in the time frame being proposed is beyond me, why must it be done now? What is the hurry? Do we get a better seat at the table in Copenhagen if we go with our scheme? Yes the Climate is changing as it has done for years, what no one is telling us is what the real detail of the treaty and the ETS are, why not? If the Liberals support this legislation the question has to be why. Malcolm get real and begin a full public debate on the issue, don't simply put together some deal that will be lost in the Christmas period and then simply become part of our legislative landscape, forever.
Posted by Katandra, 24/11/2009 7:00:38 AM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull and the Liberals' climate negotiator Ian Macfarlane.
Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull and the Liberals' climate negotiator Ian Macfarlane.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
22 November, 2009
20 November, 2009
POLL
Q: How has the deregulation of export wheat marketing affected your farm's profits this harvest?

Increased profits
(22.1%)

Decreased profits
(56.2%)

No change
(21.7%)

Total Votes: 258
Poll Date: 23 November, 2009
BLOGS
19 November, 2009

Most popular articles

SPRAY AWARDS NEWS MREC



 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...