Opinion 
 Blogs 
 The week observed 
 Bligh's blind to bushfire warning 

Bligh's blind to bushfire warning

Has Queensland Premier Anna Bligh learnt nothing from the Victorian bushfires?

Her new push to ban the clearing of regrowth vegetation would indicate not, and shows either an appalling ignorance of the environment or an equally appalling whatever-it-takes attitude to win Greens preferences to secure the up-coming State election.

It has been widely argued that the lack of control of regrowth vegetation was a contributing factor to the ferocity of the Victorian bushfires.

And while Queensland thankfully does not have a history of mega-fires like those of southern Australia, it does have a history of regular backburns conducted by graziers and before them by the Indigenous.

Instead of megafires, there are other consequences to the lack of control of vegetation regrowth.

First, regrowth diminishes productive capacity - a 2003 departmental report which the State attempted to hide from the public estimated that the economic cost was in the vicinity of $900 million (net present value over 25 years).

Second, that economic loss is caused largely by vegetation thickening, a process where the understory of scrub chokes out native grasses and thus the livestock which depends on them, leaving a bare and barren ground often susceptible to erosion. Government reports at the time warned of the environmental impact of vegetation thickening - the thicker the scrub the less native flora and fauna, with a specific threat detailed to certain parrot species which depend on native grasses.

It must be remembered that much of Queensland, and many other parts of the country, prior to white settlement, was open woodland ideal for grazing. Old graziers now report thick woodlands in areas that were open native grasslands when they were children.

Clearly the absence of fire, or alternative mechanical controls of regrowth have an affect on the environment.

But when Labor's ban on broadscale clearing was introduced to State Parliament in 2004, the Minister at the time, Stephen Robertson, explicitly warned farmers against trying to circumvent the clearing ban via the use of fire to control regrowth.

That said the Beattie Government at the time did make some limited exceptions for the control of regrowth, and the release this week of the latest landcover statistics show that 100,000 hectares of regrowth were cleared in 2006/07.

It may sound a big number, but given the size of Queensland, it should actually indicate that huge areas of regrowth are not being attended to due to the Government's regulations.

But the timing of the release of these figures by Premier Bligh would indicate that is the last thing on her mind - an election is looming and Labor's chances in key inner-city seats will depend on winning the preferences of the Greens. The Greens only sitting MP, Labor defector Ronan Lee, is an ardent anti-clearing campaigner - his seat is the leafy suburban electorate of Indooroopilly in Brisbane.

Unfortunately for rural Queenslanders, the Opposition LNP desperately needs to win Lee's seat and many other Brisbane seats if it is to have any chance of winning the election. In a bid to do so it has promised not to rollback the diabolical land clearing laws The Nationals so vehemently opposed in 2004.

The price of this kind of politics will be paid not in Brisbane though, but by the people and flora and fauna of the bush.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
My thoughts exactly! I saw red when I saw her ban on the clearing of regrowth vegetation. With the recent rains we have had grasses are man height & Brigalow regrowth is growing at the same rate.
Posted by Pam Prince, 22/02/2009 11:05:10 AM
Pollies selling their souls for political expediency. Ideas that should not be mutually dependant bond together to get them back in. Some inner city no-body gets to dictate State-wide policy from a comfy sofa. Their view on F.N.Q has as much relavence as some one from Bombay.
Posted by THE FARMER, 22/02/2009 1:27:16 PM
All the discussion about 'vegetation management' is written as it affects grazing land but we must not forget that the draconian law introduced in 2004 was State wide including the Wet Tropics. In this Biogregion, 77% of the area is protected in some way, 2% above the threshold (more than 30,000 ha above the supposed desired area). Unfortunately this State's politicians totally believe the top bureaucrats whose simplistic understanding of conservation equates to BAN CLEARING = CONSERVATION. This is far from the truth and in many situations actually results in the reverse.

Traditional owners lived on this land for centuries and traditionally burned to maintain the natural vegetation. Without this, in large areas of the Wet Tropics, the beautiful natural eucalypt forests have been lost to 'feral scrub' as others species move in to take over unmanaged forests, to the detriment of some of the very plant and animal species this ignorant State government thinks it is protecting.

Posted by green landowner, 23/02/2009 7:08:25 AM
Michael, thank you for some common sense and hopefully it will spread to the Premier, Labor and the Greens, and even the LNP. Regrowth on cleared land is not a natural phenomena, and if left uncontrolled can have serious repercussions, both environmentally (esp. no undergrowth/groundcover leading to serious erosion; and a biological desert of monoculture pioneer species) and from a production perspective. Let’s hope the legislators, pollies and voters get things into perspective and don't just grab at straws to get the, sometimes regrettably, naive ear of the city voter.
Posted by antonbiz, 23/02/2009 10:13:17 AM
The Premier, Labor and the Greens are so engrossed in this debate about green house emissions and land clearing that they can't see that Australia is getting so bogged down in laws for this and laws for that, that the poor graziers and farmers are going broke shelling out for all the paper work that they have to fill out and pay for. A fee to lodge each form at each turn (just revenue raising) instead of being able just get on with the job they love. Our Primary Industries producers get rorted at every turn especially when they try to get a fair price for their produce at the market. And graziers can't get more than approx $3.80-$4.00 per kg at a half decent sale for his cattle and the Supermarket Giants are selling the same meat to you and I in the city at $22.00-$38.00 per kg. I can see a problem here can't you???? Too much is imported into our beautiful, bountiful country that can be grown by our farmers. Oranges from the USA, asparagus from Peru!!!! And now the politicians want to let unscrupulous importers bring in bananas which are full of diseases from Asia. This will ruin our disease free industry in Nth Queensland!!!! WE HAVE TO SAY NO AT THE POLLS. Australian farmers can grow better produce and Australian shoppers want Aussie Produce. Back off politicians and let us earn a fair day's pay for a fair day's work like the rest of the world.
Posted by City girl from the Bush, 23/02/2009 2:41:31 PM
Take a trip up to Cooktown (FNQ). Then attempt take a stroll up "Grassy Hill" (the steep little hill that the good Captain climbed daily to study the layout of the coral reefs that holed his ship). Cook would made the ascent at a stroll while in more recent days, a D7 would be handy!!
Posted by Fred, 23/02/2009 11:04:59 PM
Well said City girl from the Bush. How could anyone from the city or the bush trust Labor. When the 'vegetation management' laws were introduced, landowners were told to pay yet another fee to get a PMAV (Property Map of Accessible Vegetation) which locked in cleared land and regrowth.....forever, we were told, even when the regrowth became remnant. Now, Anna Bligh and her dinosaur greens, want to go back on their word and control regrowth. Deception!
Posted by Green farmer, 25/02/2009 8:11:21 AM
I cant wait for this early election, the sooner we can be rid of the Bligh Blight the better. Another flag she's waving for the greens is the reef - http://www.newsweekly.com.au/articles/2006apr29_e.html We've golden soil and wealth for toil, Our home is girt by sea: Our land abounds in nature's gifts Of beauty rich and rare, In history's page let every stage Advance Australia fair Time to go, Bligh.
Posted by ><((((:>, 25/02/2009 5:01:27 PM
I agree wholeheartedly with your comment 'city girl from the bush' - if we aren't allowed to clear re-growth on farming land there won't be any land left to grow anything, stock or fruit and vegetables. However, can you please tell me where I can get $3-4.00 live weight for our stock? Or did you mean hot dressed carcasse weight? If it is $3-4.00 live weight I'll load them up today! With the market as it has been in recent years most graziers unfortunately don't get anything like that nowadays. Barb
Posted by well said city girl from the bush!, 25/02/2009 7:51:59 PM
Absolute madness. One firefighter returning to NSW from the Victorian bushfires stated that they had conducted fuel loads in unburnt areas. Fuel loads were from 30 to 150 tonnes/hectare. This is bark, leaves and tigs on the ground below the tree canopies. No wonder the fires are uncontrollable. All because of Victorian government policies (mainly to satisfy the Greens for voting preferences) to not allow hazard reduction burning. Also local government regulations preventing home owners from removing trees from around houses etc.
Posted by Ex Firie, 27/02/2009 4:51:37 PM
1 | 2  |  next >
Michael Thomson is the Editor of FarmOnline. He has previously worked as the Canberra Parliamentary Press Gallery correspondent for the Rural Press group of agricultural newspapers, and as a senior reporter with Queensland Country Life.
Related Coverage
POLL
Q: Will Senator Xenophon's $900m package for the Murray Darling do more harm than good?

Yes - accelerating the water buyback will hurt communities
(52.7%)

No - the sooner licences are bought back the better
(33.1%)

Undecided
(14.2%)

Total Votes: 809
Poll Date: 15 February, 2009

Most popular articles

SPRAY AWARDS NEWS MREC



The Land







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...